We talk to four women about their views on dating rules from who should pay for the first date to their best and worst date experiences.
Meet the Ladies
-
P.Y.T 27, Engineer, NYC
-
Lily A., 23, Full time student and Sales Associate, Chicago, IL.
-
Mamba, 21, Barista, Ottawa
-
Sara, 21, Independent Contractor, Haughton, Louisiana
-
1. As a woman would you walk up to a man and introduce yourself or would you wait to be noticed? Give a reason.
P.Y.T: Not only would I do this, I have done this. Not often. But its definitely happened, with favorable results as well. For me it really depends on the situation, the atmosphere of where we are and my mood. Some guys really find it attractive to have a woman make a move. Usually I’ll flash a smile or a “I think your hot” look his way and see if he reciprocates.
At that point, if I’m feeling ballsy I’ll decide if I want to approach him. I’ll usually wait a little while before I make my way over and say something feisty to break the ice. One time, on an especially ballsy night I asked this really hot guy “Why the fuck are you wearing a pin stripe suit to the bar?” as a way to break the ice…clearly this could have gone either way…he could have been insulted and walked away or as it turns out he totally ate it up and ultimately asked for my number.
Lily: I've done both. Sometimes I feel adventurous so I'll walk up to someone and introduce myself. More often than not, I will just walk up to the person. I like being assertive.
Mamba: Right now? No way in hell, I'm taken.When I was single...in a heartbeat, but only if the chemistry was right.
Sara: It would really depend on what kind of mood I'm in, but I would most likely walk up and introduce myself. I'm pretty great at starting conversations with random people.
2. Would ask a guy for the first date?
P.Y.T: Well being a member of the online dating community I have asked a guy for a first date. As for actual human, in person, interaction I have on occasion said to a guy “We should totally grab drinks sometime” as a way to indicate we should go on a date. They almost always say yes…I think a guy likes having some of the pressure taken off of them. And by me saying we should grab drinks it makes it very casual and non-threatening. I do make it a point to try and read the guy though, if he is your traditional type then I usually let him to the asking.
Lily: I would and have. I think some guys are relieved when a girl asks them out. It takes courage to put yourself out there.
Mamba: Big no no. A man should ask, it's all part of the chase.
Sara: I probably wouldn't specifically ask him out as in "Will you go on a date with me?" but I would ask him out as in "Hey, we should go together to see that movie this weekend!" which is exactly what I did with my now-fiancee.
3. On the first date do you let the man pick you up from home or do you meet in a public place?
P.Y.T : I usually like the meet the guy wherever we are going. It’s a first date and you never know how its going to go. Much better to have your own way out of there in case it completely sucks…can you even imagine how much the car ride home would suck if you just spent the last few hours wanting to strangle him from across the table.
Lily: For a first date. I like meeting in a public place. If things go well, then I'll let him take me home. If the night was disastrous, I'll ask a friend to pick me up or take a cab home.
Mamba: Depends on how you meet him. If it's through friends then at home is fine.
Sara: It depends on how well I know the guy. If it's someone I don't know that well, I like to meet in a public place just in case they're miserably boring - then I can take my car and get out of there. (A lesson I really should have learned before THE LONGEST DATE OF MY LIFE.)
4. Who do you think should pay on the first date?
P.Y.T: This is tough. I really like the school of thought that whoever does the asking is the one who pays. Although, no guy I have ever gone out with has allowed me to pay on the first date. I always pull out my wallet to offer to pay for my half, especially since I tend to feel awkward when people pay for me, but I’m always turned down. I hope my efforts are appreciated as much as me being taken care of is.
Lily: Who ever asked the other out should pay, or each paying their own share. I think it's perfectly fine for me to pay for a date if I asked the person out. I don't think it's fair that the guy pay every single date.
Mamba: The man! I'm not a gold digger, but any kind of man that doesn't pay for the first date is NOT a man...he's a boy.
Sara: Either the dude or go dutch. I prefer for the man to pay for one thing (for instance, dinner), and I'll pay for the other activity (for instance, movie tickets).
5. What kind of questions are you not supposed to ask on your first date?
P.Y.T : Anything pertaining to past relationships is 100% off the table. No questions, no debates, no ifs-ands-or buts…do not ever ask about the past on a first date. What a way to bring down the mood. You’re on a date with each other because neither of you wants to be with your ex…so keep them out of the picture and focus on each other. For example, if a guy tries to ask me about my ex on a first date I’ll say something like “If I wanted to think or talk about him I wouldn’t be here with you…so what else would you like to know?” Save the recaps of your old relationship for your friends and focus on the hottie your with.
Aside from this, I really don’t believe in “supposed to”…you need to take each date individually and see where things go. See what’s comfortable and don’t worry about what your “supposed to” be saying or doing. It will become obvious if your more focused on what not to say than if you just speak naturally.
Lily: I never asked about income on a first date. I think that's weird. Never talk about sex on the first date.
Mamba: I can't really think of it... but no heavy hitting subjects like religion or politics. Keep it light and fun.
Sara: How many people have you had sex with?" "What should we name our first child?" "If I were to tie you up to a chair, break both your legs, and force you to sit here with me and love me and be my partner for life, would you be upset?" One question you ALWAYS need to ask on the first date? "When the zombie apocolypse happens, will you try to save me or kill me if I turn into a zombie?"
6. If the date is going all wrong, how do you end it?
P.Y.T: I am completely guilty of using the “Oh my god my friend just got broken up with and she’s devastated…I have to go, I’m soo sorry!” I felt so pathetic after that I never used it again…one and done. Now I tend to schedule dates which would be intentionally short as a first date…ices, drinks, coffee…to avoid the need for an excuse. But in case I need one I usually just say how tired I am and how early I need to be up the next day so I really should get going.
Lily: If there is no way to salvage the night, I'll do the "tv sitcom thing". You know, where they have a friend call them to see how the date is going. And if the night is bad they'll say, "Oh my god you were in an accident?! Which ER are you at? I'm coming right away!".
Mamba: If he is a bad date, I would just walk right out.If he was a nice guy, but there was no chemistry...stick it out.
Sara: "Um, yeah, I'm really tired" *fake yawn"
7. How much should you tell about yourself on your first date?
P.Y.T: Well, no need to give your unabridged autobiography when you first meet a person but like I already said, there really is no “should”. If the date is going well you will want to see this person again and keep them interested and guessing about you so if you lay the cards out on the table from the get go there is nothing left for them to get to know about you.
Boring! And really, if you can get your whole life story out in a first date either your really fucking boring or your completely monopolizing the conversation which is just selfish. So answer whatever questions are being asked but keep it short and sweet. First dates are like an interviews, you need to be prepared to talk about yourself and be open and honest without offering too much information...you wouldn’t exactly tell a perspective employer about the time you drank so much tequila you threw up all over the back seat of a cab…so don’t tell your date either (yet!)
Lily: The good thing to do is answer each question asked truthfully.
Mamba: Just enough for him to get a feel for who you are and what you're about.
Sara: You probably shouldn't talk about that time you killed someone on the side of the interstate as a dare.
8. Describe your best and worst date?
P.Y.T: My best date had to be with this guy I met online. We chatted once or twice before getting together and the conversation was great. We had plans to grab drinks and figured if things went well we would take it from there. So we met at the bar and the conversation just flowed. Before I got out we were already planning the second date.
My worst date…hard to really just pick one…and I feel like if I do it would be unfair to all the guys who were equally as heinous. So to most accurately answer this question I will describe some of the things that make a date awful. For one thing when a guy has nothing to say. I am a talkative outgoing person so it’s important for me to be with someone who is a good conversationalist. I have been on too many dates where I get one word answers back or hear so much stupid shit coming out of a guys mouth that it took every ounce of self control not to laugh hysterically in their face. Also, someone who is too touchy feely and doesn’t respect boundaries is not going to get a positive review…I’m not against kissing on the first date if things are going really well…I am, however, against someone being so ignorant that they believe me sitting there with my arms and legs crossed and my body clearly turned in the other direction somehow means I want them to touch me or try to kiss me.
Lily: My best date was last year. We went to the art museum before dinner. At dinner we had an awesome table, we talked as if we had known each other for years. I didn't feel weird about eating salmon (nothing else seemed appetizing on the menu). It was beautiful. After dinner we went to the symphony, which I usually find boring, but it was amazing with him. Unfortunately, things didn't work out, but we're still good friends.
My worst date was a few years back. It was so bad it made me cry when I got home. I had theater class with this guy, and he asked me out on a date. For class we had to go to a play and after the play he invited me out to lunch. It started out fine. We had a nice conversation, and we talked about our hopes and dreams. It was my 20th birthday, so he went up to our waitress and asked for a sundae. 10 minutes later, she came back with a sundae with a candle singing happy birthday. "Happy birthday, dear Elizabeth! Happy birthday to you!" What? My date thought my name was Elizabeth? And on my birthday? Not to mention, I had to pay because the place we went to didn't accept credit cards, and he promised to pay me back. 3 years later, I'm still waiting for my payment.
Mamba: Best: My Boyfriend and I used to live in different cities. Whenever he would come up I would show him my favorite places in the city and then we would do corny things like paddle boating. It was fun because it was like showing him more about me.
Worst: Honestly, I've never had a bad date. I've had a really awkward date...the guy was a sweetheart, but I just wasn't feeling it.
Sara: Worst? The longest date ever. It lasted from 9 in the morning until 11 at night, and I wanted to stab myself in the face THE ENTIRE TIME. Best? My first date with my now-fiancee.
9. Is it okay to call a man after your first date or should he make the first move?
P.Y.T: While I admit to making the first move after a date…usually with a text to say I had a great time…I’m traditional so I really enjoy and appreciate when a guy makes the effort to contact me. I don’t see anything wrong with the girl contacting the guy but just be smart about it so you don’t come on too strong or make yourself look desperate.
Lily: I've never been good with this. I don't want to seem desperate to a guy. But I also don't want to seem uninterested to a guy I'm interested in. But if it's been a week and I haven't heard anything, I might text them or email them saying, "hey, I had a great time the other day! Just wanted to see how you're doing".
Mamba: He'll call you if he's into you.
Sara: It's okay to call a man. If he likes talking on the phone, that is. I hate talking on the phone so I am more of a texter than a caller. And there is nothing wrong with texting after a first date as long as you aren't approaching stalker territory.
10. When do you think is the right time to discuss an ex?
P.Y.T: Never? But that’s clearly unrealistic it. Everyone has a past and everyone is addicted to talking and asking about it. So inevitably the ex conversation will happen. Id say to try and postpone any serious ex conversations till the two of you have gone out a couple of times…by that point you probably wouldn’t even care so much…but before that is just unnecessary.
Lily: I try not to bring up an ex, unless I'm specifically asked about them. If I'm not asked about them, I just leave them where they are: in the past. I do hate being on a date, and the entire conversation is about my date's ex.
Mamba: At least 3 dates in. At leasttt.
Sara: You should NEVER discuss past encounters you had with an ex. If you do talk about an
ex, don't mention names. Relay the anecdote quickly and move on. Otherwise you should fear the wrath of WOMAN.
11. When should be the first kiss?
P.Y.T: Whenever it feels right! I've kissed in the middle of a first date, the end, on the second date. You need to just live in the moment for this one, plain and simple.
Lily: When it feels right. Sometimes, the first date feels right. You just know. Sometimes the third date feels right.
Mamba: With tongue, maybe third date.
Sara: Whenever you want it to be. Personally, I want to be kissed after a first date if there's been a vibe all night.
12. When should the first meeting of friends take place?
P.Y.T: Personally, I don’t like the idea of introducing my friends to all these guys that may not stick around. Usually I wait until I know I’ll be bringing him around more than once…I feel by that point he and I are more comfortable around each other which makes it easier when either of you are meeting each other’s friends. Meeting friends can be nerve-wracking so if the two of you are at least past that initial, awkward getting to know you phase it makes things a little more enjoyable.
Lily: I think within the first month. My friends are very important to me, and if a guy is going to be in my life, I want my friends to know him and vice versa.
Mamba: 2 months
Sara: A month or so after you start dating. And it should be in a casual setting.
13. When do you meet parents?
P.Y.T: I haven’t had to worry about this one in a while. My last relationship was with someone I was incredibly good friends with prior to dating so meeting parents already happened. I know my sister introduced her boyfriend to my parents after they were dating for a few months. I think depending how things are going no sooner then 3-6mths would be appropriate.
Lily: With in the first 6 months, but not within the first three. Maybe even a year into the relationship.
Mamba: My parents are old fashioned, so I've got to make sure he's worth it. It took me like 8 months.
Sara: At the wedding
14. Do you think dating rules have changed, and if so, how?
P.Y.T: The word rules bothers me just as much as the word should. I feel like anyone who tries to date by following rules is just dumb. Dating is something that depends on an individual…there is no cookie cutter formula to how you find your person.
Talk to 10 people and you will get 10 different stories. You may find some things in common but the path they took will be different then you will. Trying to follow a rule will just leave you upset and wondering what you’re doing wrong when things don’t work out…and frankly, the only thing you are doing wrong is trying to follow a rule!!!
I do, however, believe there are trends in dating and I absolutely believe those have changed. For example…more people than ever are dating online. Just a few years ago this had such a negative stigma attached to it and now almost every person i know does it. Also, everyone sends text messages these days. Whether it’s to ask how your day is going, tell you they are thinking of you or to ask you on a date…a text seems to be the dating substitute for an actual conversation.
Lily: I think so. I think that things like "the man pays" or "the man asks you out" are no longer the norm. I think if you want to be in a relationship with someone it should be equal. A way to show this equality a woman must take the role of asking someone out.
Mamba: Yes, but women have to remember... just because we have the right to be outspoken and more forward they have to remember that men like the chase. They want to feel like you're a catch and they want to feel like they are the man. Men are always going to be men.
Sara: Definitely. Women can do more now, and that's pretty nice. Except for the whole helping pay thing. That part sucks.